Quick answer: Before hiring an SEO company, ask what they will actually do, how they choose keywords, whether they understand website structure, how they measure results, and whether they can explain their strategy without hiding behind buzzwords. If they cannot explain it clearly, that is your first warning sign.
The Short Answer
Before hiring an SEO company, ask what they will actually do, how they choose keywords, whether they understand website structure, how they measure results, and whether they can explain their strategy without hiding behind buzzwords.
If they cannot explain it clearly, that is your first warning sign.
A lot of SEO companies sell confidence better than they sell results.
They will talk about backlinks, rankings, secret systems, monthly reports, and how long they have been doing SEO. That does not mean they are good.
The question is simple: do they understand how Google reads a website, how your customers search, and how your site needs to be built to actually bring in leads?
What Exactly Will You Do Each Month?
Do not accept vague answers.
If they say "optimization", ask what that means.
You want specifics:
- What pages will be worked on?
- What content will be created?
- What technical issues will be fixed?
- What internal links will be added?
- What keywords are being targeted?
- What will be reported?
- What happens after the first month?
If they cannot explain the monthly work, there may not be much work happening.
Do You Look at the Website Structure?
This is a big one.
SEO is not just adding blogs to a bad website. If the site structure is weak, the service pages are thin, the navigation is confusing, and Google cannot understand what you offer, you have a problem.
Ask if they review:
- Service page structure
- URL structure
- Internal linking
- Navigation
- Page speed
- Indexing
- Technical issues
- Conversion paths
If they only talk about backlinks, be careful.
How Do You Choose Keywords?
Bad SEO agencies chase keywords without understanding buyer intent.
A keyword with traffic is not always a keyword that makes money.
Ask how they choose keywords and whether they look at:
- Buyer intent
- Local intent
- Competition
- Current rankings
- Service value
- Search volume
- Difficulty
- Conversion potential
You do not just want more visitors. You want better leads.
Do You Create or Improve Service Pages?
For most businesses, service pages matter more than blogs.
Blogs help, but service pages usually bring in the buyers who are closer to taking action.
Ask if they will improve existing service pages or create new ones. If they only plan to write generic blog posts, that is not enough.
See What Is Holding Your Website Back
Book a free website and SEO audit. I will tell you what is working, what is broken, and what to fix first.
Book a Free AuditWhat Is Your Backlink Strategy?
Backlinks are where a lot of SEO gets shady.
Ask where the links come from, why they matter, and whether they are relevant.
If they are selling huge backlink numbers for cheap, run.
A few good links can be useful. A pile of garbage links can make your site look worse.
How Do You Measure Success?
Ranking reports are useful, but they are not the whole story.
Ask if they track:
- Organic traffic
- Phone calls
- Form fills
- Keyword movement
- Indexed pages
- Conversions
- Google Search Console data
- Landing page performance
If the report looks fancy but does not connect to business results, it is not good enough.
Can You Show Me What Is Wrong with My Website Right Now?
A good SEO company should be able to spot real issues before asking you to sign.
They may not give away the full strategy for free, but they should be able to explain what is holding the site back.
If every answer sounds generic, the strategy will probably be generic too.
Red Flags
- Guaranteed rankings
- Cheap backlink packages
- No audit
- No clear deliverables
- No mention of website structure
- No mention of technical SEO
- No mention of conversions
- No access to Google Search Console
- No explanation of what will be done
- Too much jargon
What I Would Do If I Owned Your Business
I would ask for a plain English explanation of the plan.
No buzzwords. No hiding.
I would want to know what is broken, what needs to be built, what can realistically improve, and what the first 90 days look like.
If they cannot explain SEO like a normal person, I would not trust them with my website.
Frequently Asked Questions
Get an Honest Look at Your Website
Before you hire an SEO company, let Devebyte take a look. Book a free audit and I will tell you what I see, what I would fix, and whether SEO makes sense for your business.
Book a Free Audit